In the same way my barely legible teenage penmanship has devolved across a quarter-century of digital document creation, my instincts to pause and save a game waned. I attribute this to the emergence of automatic saving, save points, console quick-resume features, and experiences where the risk feels so great that I instinctively save every two seconds for fear of catastrophic failure. Yet, I am fallible. Laziness creeps in. And this week, I learned an important lesson eight hours into the recently released Pokémon FireRed on the Switch: one must always remember to save your game.
Many years had gone by since I engaged with one of the 2D Pokémon games — as I skipped the GBA era, the Generation II titles may have been the final core Pokémon game I completed. So I was pumped to pay twenty dollars for the nostalgic return to the land of the original 151, and a quest gathering those first 151 creatures. I immediately snapped back to my youth. Across several nights, I snagged Caterpie and Weedle, found a Pikachu in Viridian Forest, knocked out Brock on my first turn, gambled on buying the Magikarp from a shady character, and journeyed through Mt. Moon without a worry in the world.
The critical error: Not once did I save! And never thought to.
Jigglypuff will never find love with my Mankey.
Disaster struck one evening where I didn’t play FireRed… and where my kid took the console for a swift 30 minutes of the newer Pokémon title in its place, quitting my application to do so. As any Switch user understands (as I should have known…) opening a new game on the system closes the active game. Your data is only preserved when an autosave triggers or you saved manually before switching. Whoops.
The Evolution of Game Saves: From Deliberate to Seamless
One could view autosave, now so seamless many gamers take it for granted, as a bona fide “next-generation” innovation. Whereas the early computer game Zork featured among the first save functions in a game, 1986’s The Legend of Zelda is often credited as a pivotal point for not feeling utterly defeated following a character's death due to persistent memory saves on NES cartridges. Of course, you still had to remember to save. (And following a single mistake), the lesson was learned for life. Through the 1990s, external memory cards like PlayStation made saving more common but remained precarious; neglecting to save (or losing a card) could wipe hours of progress. Games like Resident Evil went so far as to make saving into a scarce commodity.
Contemporary background saving, that eroded my instinct to save my Pokémon adventure so completely, took hold in the early 2000s. The original Halo pioneered seamless respawn points whereas later franchises like Call of Duty honed the approach to smooth difficulty and reduce tedious replay. As the play grew longer — and increasingly non-linear — programmers mastered the technique for saving without interruption and, in time, the ultimate convenience of picking up exactly where you left off.
The Pokémon Series' Path: From Conscious Choice to Unconscious Backup
Funny enough, the Pokémon series serves as a perfect mirror of how saving has changed. For decades, preserving your Pokédex progress required a manual command: players were trained to manually record their data before closing their Game Boy or DS. The shift began with Pokémon Sword and Shield for the Nintendo Switch, the games added autosave (initially optional), marking a major design shift within one of the industry's most slowest-changing series.
I own up to my blunder: Years of playing Breath of the Wild and modern Mario games utterly weakened my instinct to save. I still know better under specific circumstances — I refuse to chance exiting prematurely in a challenging indie title despite being aware it saves progress automatically — but be it because the lengthy gap since I last invested older game design, or modern conveniences have softened me, I didn't even think to preserve my progress before redocking. Seven-year-old me would have been more diligent so catastrophically.
The Consequences: Starting From Scratch
I have not picked up FireRed after my data loss incident. When I loaded it back up to see I had only the beginning Squirtle, my motivation evaporated. My personal status: Burned.
Perhaps I'll restart… or I could just continue playing the ocean of contemporary releases available now which gently presume I need my hand held. However, my love for retro gaming persists. When I can pry my child to take a break from her current favorite, we enjoy playing together some retro multiplayer mayhem. Those early SNES games omitted saving entirely opting instead for cryptic character strings. Thus, when I make a fatal mistake, it’s not a total loss. That, at least, is reassuring.